Ousmane Dembele Wins Ballon d’Or 2025 but Critics Say He Lacks

Ohana Magazine – Ousmane Dembele officially claimed the Ballon d’Or 2025 at the Theatre du Chatelet in Paris on Tuesday (September 23). The French forward outperformed strong contenders such as Lamine Yamal and Vitinha to secure football’s most prestigious individual award. At 28 years old, this triumph represents the pinnacle of Dembele’s career, a recognition that many believed inevitable after his remarkable season with Paris Saint-Germain.

Outstanding Achievements with Paris Saint-Germain

The award did not come without merit. Dembele played a vital role in PSG’s treble-winning campaign, recording an impressive 35 goals across 53 matches in all competitions. His attacking brilliance, speed, and technical skill consistently made the difference in crucial games. Observers widely agree that his on-field performances provided the strongest case for his Ballon d’Or success, cementing his reputation as one of Europe’s most dangerous forwards.

Mixed Reactions from Spanish Journalists

However, despite his achievements, not everyone feels convinced about Dembele’s stature as a global football icon. Spanish journalist Luis Nieto argued that the French winger lacks the charisma usually associated with Ballon d’Or winners. He even expressed surprise that Pedri, another standout performer, finished as low as 11th in the rankings. “Dembele’s goals and trophies speak for themselves, but in terms of charisma, he falls short,” Nieto remarked.

Praise for His Consistency and Winning Mentality

On the other hand, another Spanish journalist, Tomas Roncero, emphasized that Dembele fully deserved the honor. According to Roncero, the winger’s consistency and ability to deliver in high-pressure matches made him the natural choice. “The uncertainty has ended, and the crown goes to Ousmane Dembele,” he stated, underlining the extraordinary season that justified the recognition.

The Debate Around Charisma and Football Greatness

The contrasting opinions reflect a broader debate about what defines football greatness. While statistics, trophies, and performances are crucial, many also expect Ballon d’Or winners to embody leadership, charisma, and influence both on and off the field. Dembele’s critics believe he excels in numbers but has yet to capture the aura that elevates players into legendary figures.

Looking Ahead to Dembele’s Next Chapter

For Dembele, the challenge now lies in maintaining his form and silencing doubts about his character. Winning the Ballon d’Or has placed him among the elite, but the journey ahead will determine whether he can transform perception and build a legacy that extends beyond statistics. As PSG prepares for another demanding season, all eyes will remain on the French star to see if he can combine performance with presence.